Most of us know Natalie Portman for her roles in Black Swan, No String Attached, and my favorites Star Wars Episodes I-III. Her list of roles in very long besides that and she has also taken to [executive] producing, like in this movie. It took me a lot longer to place where I had seen her co-star Scott Cohen, who it turns out was in The Carrie Diaries, among other things. I can't talk about the cast without mentioning Lisa Kudrow, who I should not even have to explain more. Charlie Tahan also did a great job of being a slight comedic relief and a serious part of the plot.
Speaking of the plot, it was very different from what I was expecting. I had not looked this movie up much prior to watching it, so I just assumed it was going to be some comedy about a girl dating a married guy and her friends maybe talking her out of it. I was completely wrong, but not at all disappointed. The Other Woman shows Amelia Greenleaf (Portman) as she tries to move on with the death of her newborn daughter, Isabel, while also trying to maintain her relationships with her husband and step-son. What makes the grieving process harder than normal is, as we find out, that Amelia and her husband Jack (Cohen) got married basically because of the baby after conceiving her during an affair. Jack's son, Will (Tahan), initially has trouble with understanding how much sadness surrounded the death and why it caused Amelia to react the way she did to certain things, like selling the baby's things.
As Amelia moves through her stages of grief, she learns a lot about herself and her new family. Jack's ex-wife, Carolyn (Kudrow), gives Amelia the most trouble--which it is kind of easy to see why, but she does go a bit overboard. At this troubling time, Amelia's mom happens to decide to start to date Amelia's dad again, who basically used to be a sex addict. It takes a very long time, and some yelling, for Amelia to understand this-all of which puts more strain on her and Jack's complicated relationship, who is also grieving and keeping an eye out for Will. In addition to all of that, Jack has to find out that Amelia thinks she killed their baby by suffocating her, but we find out it really was SIDS all along. We follow Amelia as she gets one blow after another, but it all boils down to what we started with: a family. By the end it is a happier one, even if they are broken once or twice.
Like I said, this movie was a tearjerker. It would have been even more so if I had to see Natalie
Portman's face as she told the story of how she killed her baby (because her acting crying face is better than my real one), but the movie did something with that scene that I found interesting. They show a majority of the flashback to the events following Isabel's death through the couple's bedroom doorway. It would have been too much for anyone to handle if the camera was closer into the scene. We see different times through the doorways while the rest of the screen stays black--like we are standing in the hallway. I still had my hand over my face in shock as I watched, but seeing someone else actually cry would have been just personally more heart wrenching. I felt that this use of lighting, perspective, and storytelling was very well done. The movie also uses this set up during the end of the scene as Amelia leaves her husband crying in their bedroom as he grieves from the new information of how his daughter died.
To be completely honest, I shed a couple tears during this movie, which I do not do for just any sad films. I am thankful for Will because he had his little moments of kid talk and logic that lightened things up a bit. I thought the actors all did very well, especially Lisa Kudrow (coming from the happy world of Phoebe) and my girl Natalie Portman. The only reason I am not giving this movie a 4 is because I gave Manhattan a 4 and Manhattan was just so beautiful (don't get me started on the bridge scene), so I give The Other Woman 3.5 out of 5 stars!